Homemade Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer

Sharing is caring

Ditch the artificial coffee creamers loaded with sugar and mystery ingredients. This homemade pumpkin spice coffee creamer is made with real pumpkin, warm spices, and simple ingredients to bring the cozy vibes of fall.

Hello Pumpkin Spice Season

I always look forward to the first cup of coffee during the fall. I love to sit on the porch when the mornings get crisp and the light shifts; all I want is something warm and comforting in my hands – preferably something that tastes like cinnamon and coffee. That’s when pumpkin spice season comes knocking. But every time I grabbed a seasonal creamer off the shelf, I’d scan the back and cringe. Between artificial flavors, added sugar, and ingredients that sounded more like lab experiments than food, I knew I could do better.

So I did.

I created a creamy, dreamy, real pumpkin coffee creamer that checks all the boxes: cozy, hormone-friendly, and downright delicious.

My Pumpkin Creamer Obsession

When I moved to the US, I quickly realized just how iconic pumpkin spice had become. The classic pumpkin spice latte seemed to be everyone’s favorite fall tradition. My friends raved about their first PSL of the season as if it were a national holiday. I tried one, and I got it – the flavors of pumpkin, cinnamon, and vanilla were nostalgic and comforting. However, upon checking the nutritional information, I realized it contained a sugar bomb and ingredients I couldn’t pronounce. Not something I wanted as part of my daily diet.

That’s when I started experimenting in my kitchen. What if I could make a creamer that delivered all those comforting fall flavors without the questionable ingredients? What if it could actually nourish me instead of making me crash before lunch?

Spoiler: I cracked the code.

As a chef and nutrition consultant, I’m always looking for ways to combine pleasure with nourishment. I believe food should not only taste good but also be good for your body. This pumpkin spice coffee creamer is one of my favorite ways to upgrade a daily habit into something hormone-supportive and soul-satisfying. It’s rich in healthy fats, gently spiced, lightly sweetened, and absolutely free of synthetic additives. Whether you’re using oat milk, almond milk, or classic heavy cream, you’re in for a deliciously better way to enjoy your morning coffee.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• It’s made with real pumpkin and warm spices that taste like fall in a cup.
• No refined sugar, artificial flavors, or preservatives—just natural goodness.
• Easily customizable for dairy-free or low-sugar lifestyles.
• Pairs beautifully with hot coffee, cold brew, or even your favorite chai.
• Stores well in the fridge for the whole week.
• Feels like a coffee shop treat, without the price tag or the sugar crash.

This website may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you if you purchase through these links. As an affiliate, I only recommend products or services I genuinely use and love. Check the affiliate disclosure here.

Ingredient Substitutions

• If you’re avoiding dairy, opt for oat milk, almond milk, or cashew milk.
• For a richer texture, full-fat coconut milk or whole milk work beautifully.
• If maple syrup isn’t your thing, try honey or a sugar substitute like monk fruit.
• No pumpkin pie spice? Mix your own with cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and cloves.

If you need help picking the right milk for your texture and health needs, you might enjoy some of my practical tips in How To Balance And Maximize Flavors When Cooking.

For more inspiration on how different milks and creams affect texture, check out my tips in this Copycat Starbucks Cinnamon Dolce Latte.

Health Benefits for Women’s Health

• Pumpkin is rich in beta-carotene, which supports the immune system and promotes healthy skin. It’s also a good source of fiber and vitamin C, both important for metabolic and hormonal function.More pumpkin inspiration: If you’re a fan of pumpkin drinks, my Homemade Pumpkin Latte recipe pairs beautifully with this creamer. You’ll get double the comfort!
• Cinnamon helps regulate blood sugar, which can reduce cravings and stabilize mood swings—especially helpful during perimenopause.
• Coconut milk provides healthy fats that support brain health and hormone production.
• Maple syrup, in moderation, is less processed than refined sugar and contains trace minerals like manganese and zinc.
• The spices (ginger, nutmeg, cloves) have anti-inflammatory and digestive benefits, which are crucial for women’s health and overall vitality. Using real spices—especially when you know all about the flavor benefits of ingredients like cinnamon from resources such as Cinnamon, the king of winter spices—gives you a depth of taste that powdered or artificial mixes just can’t match.

Chef Angie’s Tips

• Use fresh pumpkin puree if you’ve got leftover roasted pumpkin—it gives amazing flavor.
• Whisk constantly while warming to prevent sticking.
• Want it extra smooth? Blend it before bottling.
• Make a double batch and gift a jar to your favorite fall-loving friend.

Keto and Low-Sugar Options

For anyone watching their carbs, there’s an easy path to making homemade pupmking spice creamer and creamy coffee without the sugar rush. All you need is a few swaps:

• Choose unsweetened almond, macadamia, or coconut milk as your base. These keep carbs low and bring a clean, mild backdrop for spices.
• Pick a keto-friendly sweetener. Monk fruit drops or liquid stevia create sweetness with basically zero carbs. Start small and build up gradually since keto sweeteners can be intense.
• Dial in your spice blend. With less sugar, a little more cinnamon, nutmeg, or clove brings out the pumpkin flavor and adds interest.

If you need ideas for cozy add-ons that fit into keto plans, think about sprinkling in crushed Macadamia Nuts with Cinnamon Glaze for crunch and a sweet-spiced accent.

Ways to Serve

• In your hot morning coffee or afternoon espresso.
• With cold brew for a fall-inspired iced coffee.
• Froth it and pour over a shot of espresso for your own pumpkin spice latte.
• Stir into chai or matcha for a seasonal twist.
• Use it as a drizzle on pancakes or French toast.

Storage

Pour the finished creamer into an airtight container or mason jar and refrigerate. It’ll keep well for 5–7 days. Give it a good shake before each use, as natural separation will occur.

Equipment

You don’t need anything fancy to make this work:

• A medium saucepan
• A whisk
• A mason jar or bottle with a lid
• A fine mesh strainer (optional)

FAQ

Can I make this dairy-free?

Yes, it’s delicious with almond milk, oat milk, cashew milk, or full-fat coconut milk.

How much sugar is in it?

That depends on your sweetener. Maple syrup adds about 3–4 grams of sugar per tablespoon. You can reduce that or use a sugar substitute to lower the total sugars.

Can I freeze it?

You can, but it may separate a bit when thawed. For best texture, use it fresh within a week.

How is it different from store-bought pumpkin spice creamer?

Store-bought versions often contain artificial and natural flavors, stabilizers, and more sugar than you need in a single serving of food. This version uses whole, recognizable ingredients that support your health instead of draining it.

What kind of milk works best?

It depends on your preference. For richness, go with coconut milk or heavy cream. For light and neutral, almond milk or oat milk are great options.

Making your own pumpkin spice coffee creamer is a simple but powerful upgrade to your daily ritual. It’s about more than flavor—it’s about choosing to start your day with something made from real food, with real benefits, that brings real joy.

It’s fall in a jar. And honestly, it’s one of my favorite things about this time of year.

Let me know how it turns out for you. What’s your favorite way to use this creamer? Share in the comments or send me a photo—I’d love to see your cozy creations.

Hungry For More?

18 Fall Soups, Stews, And Fall Recipes

Top 15 Thanksgiving Soup Recipes You Need to Try This Fall

Pumpkin Salsa Recipe With Apple

Turkey Pumpkin Chili Recipe (Paleo, Whole30)

Celeriac Puree (Celery Root Puree- Puree Z Selera)

Polish Cream of Celery Root Soup (Zupa Krem z Selera)

Tender Red Wine Braised Beef

Creamy Purple Sweet Potato Soup

Sharing is caring

Love My Content? Buy Me a Coffee!

Creating these resources for you is my passion, and I love hearing how they’ve helped you on your health journey. If you appreciate my content and want to support my work, you can buy me a coffee to help fuel more tips, recipes, and inspiration. Every little bit means the world to me!